For example, if as review C suggested several of my recent ancestors were indeed drawn from other species, it is too late to change that. Journal of Educational and Social Research 5 2: Recent Searches Cover letter Responding to reviewer comments Predatory publishers Research objectives Grant proposal Open access Plagiarism in research Journal selection tips Abstract Difference between thesis and journal article “Reject and Resubmit” status Scope and limitations Citations. A journal’s editor may even want you to submit two versions of the revised manuscript: You’re looking to give wings to your academic career and publication journey. Second, compose a good response letter to accompany your revised manuscript.
I shall skip the usual point-by-point description of every single change we made in response to the critiques. First, if the decision letter doesn’t spell this out, find out if revisions in your submission should be highlighted and, if so, whether change-tracking, yellow highlighting or colored text is preferred. Submission Process 10 Tips to write an effective cover letter for journal submission … Read. A sentence along the lines of “All spelling and grammatical errors pointed out by the reviewers have been corrected” suffices. Confirm that you would also like to sign up for free personalized email coaching for this stage. After each comment state succinctly how you addressed the issue in the revision-what was changed and where.
For example, if as review C suggested several of my recent ancestors were indeed drawn from other species, it is too late to change that. Confirm that you would also like to sign up for free personalized email coaching for this stage. May whatever heritage you come from resubmissin the butt of the next round of ethnic jokes.
These were on a variety of different topics, none of which had any manusccript to our work that we could see.
Tips for authors submitting a revised manuscript | Editage Insights
Covr email address will not be published. As you formulate these responses, bear in mind that the reviewers will probably read this letter. We agree with you that the paper is much better this way. This content belongs to the Journal Submission Stage.
Sample Cover Letter for Journal Manuscript Resubmissions – Academia Obscura
Goldman An experienced journal editor who feels strongly about issues like peer review and is proactive in discussing these issues with authors and others interested in publication. First, if the decision letter doesn’t spell this out, find out if revisions in your submission should be highlighted and, if so, whether change-tracking, yellow highlighting or colored text is preferred. A final word of advice: Why don’t we give you complete access! Baumeister Dear Sir, Madame, or Other: We have again rewritten the entire manuscript from start to finish.
It’s not a bad idea to start the letter by acknowledging the time and effort that the reviewers and possibly the editor have put into assessing the previous version of the manuscript.
Submission Process Editorial decision-making: To repay you, we would be happy to review some manuscripts for you; please send us the next manuscript that any of these reviewers submits to your journal. After all, it is fairly clear that your reviewers are less interested in details of scientific procedure than in working out their personality problems and sexual frustrations by seeking some kind of demented glee in the sadistic and arbitrary exercise of tyrannical power over helpless authors like ourselves who happen to fall into their clutches.
The manuscript may still contain mistakes, but you’ve shown that you’ve done what you can to minimize them. Then copy each of the reviewers’ comments into your response letter. This is particularly appropriate if the critiques were very detailed and highly constructive.
A journal’s editor may even want you to submit two versions of the revised covver It’s not necessary to respond individually to each spelling or punctuation mistake, or similar trivial errors, that the reviewers or the editor indicated on the previous version of the paper. One perplexing problem was dealing with suggestions by Reviewer B.
You’re looking to give wings to coveer academic career and publication journey. If so, share it with your fellow researchers.
If you have elected not to change the manuscript in response to a particular criticism or suggestion from the reviewers, explain why. As for the cover letter itself, my own thoughts… Teixeira da Silva, J.
If the decision letter doesn’t make this clear, go ahead and eltter the editor via e-mail. Thus, you suggested that we shorten the manuscript by 5 pages, and we were able to accomplish this very effectively by altering the margins and printing the paper in a different font with a smaller typeface.
Tips for authors submitting a revised manuscript. Still, from this batch of reviewers, C was clearly the most hostile, and we request that you not ask him or her to review this revision.
Indeed, we have mailed letter bombs to four or five people we suspected of being reviewer C, so if you send the manuscript back to them the review process could be unduly delayed. Hopefully cver have resubmission enough by now to satisfy even you and your bloodthirsty reviewers. It’s not unusual for a contributor to Polar Researchthe journal I edit, to be asked to revise her or his submission three or four times before it’s finally accepted.
We even changed the goddamn running head! You can learn more about writing a cover letter and handling peer review comments in these posts: